When it involves understanding physique weight versus BMI versus physique composition, issues can get complicated. Even extra complicated is when the numbers don’t appear fairly proper, which is precisely what occurred when actress Sarah Hyland stepped on the size to find out her physique composition (AKA how a lot of her weight is fats versus lean mass) yesterday.
“Yeah. My scale says I’m 48% fats. Soooo…how’s your Monday?” the Modern Family star captioned a photograph she posted on Instagram tales final night time. According to Hyland’s physique composition scale, she weighs 92.eight kilos, with 49% physique fats, 11% muscle, 37% water, and three% bone. Hmm.
According to the American Council on Exercise, regular physique fats percentages for ladies vary from 10% to 31%, with a physique fats proportion over 32% being thought of overweight. At 5’2” and 92 kilos, Hyland is something however overweight. So we had some questions.
RELATED: Kourtney Kardashian Weighs 98 Lbs. Here’s Why That’s Not Necessarily a Bad Thing
First off, is it even attainable to be 92 kilos and have 49% physique fats? “While it’s attainable to have that prime of a proportion of physique fats, it might be very irregular for half of her physique weight to be fats,” says Amy Rothberg, MD, director of the University of Michigan’s Weight Management Clinic.
Samuel Klein, MD, director of the Center for Human Nutrition on the Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis agrees: “Women are inclined to have extra physique fats than males, however it’s extremely unlikely that she can be 92 kilos and virtually 50% physique fats.”
RELATED: The Number One Thing You Need to Do to Lose Weight Forever, According to Experts
It’s not stunning that Hyland’s dwelling scale supplied questionable outcomes. According to Dr. Klein, there’s a lot variability in dwelling physique composition gadgets that they aren’t all the time dependable sources. Plus, physique composition scales (or the common variations, for that matter) don’t account for the distribution of fats all through the physique, which is definitely simply as necessary as the quantity of fats one carries. Why? Belly fats is linked to an elevated threat of metabolic illnesses like diabetes and coronary heart illness in comparison with fats saved within the buttocks and legs.
When assessing physique fats, it’s essential to contemplate distribution along with composition, says Dr. Klein: “Measuring your waist circumference, for instance, gives you a greater estimate of your fats distribution than stepping on a scale.”
To get our prime tales delivered to your inbox, join the Healthy Living publication
According to Dr. Rothberg, essentially the most dependable strategy to measure physique composition is with a DEXA scan or Bod Pod system, two instruments which are usually discovered at medical facilities, health clinics, or in analysis settings—not your toilet–and use high-tech strategies to check fats tissue to lean mass.
We weren’t the one ones who had been skeptical of Hyland’s dwelling scale studying. The actress captioned her physique comp rating, “Definition of #skinnyfat or my scale is damaged.” We’re going to guess it’s damaged.